Thirty romance story ideas, and the question that drives each one
By Nora K.6 min read
A premise is only half an idea. The other half is the question a reader carries from page to page: will she forgive him, will they get caught, which of them breaks first. I keep both halves in my notebook, because a premise without its question tends to stall by chapter two. Here are thirty, sorted by kind, each with its question.
How to use these
Take one and change the job, the city or the century, but keep the question. It tells you where the book ends, because the last chapter is the one that answers it.
Most of these sit on a familiar trope, and the romance tropes list says what readers will expect from each. All of the characters are adults.
Rivals and opposites
- For eleven years she has won the giant pumpkin prize at the county show, and this year a newcomer arrives with a bigger one on a borrowed trailer. Does she want to beat him, or to learn his secret?
- A town’s only weather forecaster keeps getting it wrong on the days a garden-party planner has booked, and she has started sending him the bills. How long before the complaints become an excuse to call?
- A minimalist interior designer is hired to clear the house of a man who keeps everything, and he argues for every object. Which of them changes the house, and which changes the other?
- A cookbook author famous for twenty-minute dinners is assigned a fact-checker who times every recipe. What happens when he finds the one that takes two hours, and asks why?
- A strict conductor gets a new percussionist who improvises in the quiet bars and is, annoyingly, right every time. Does she fire him, or rewrite the piece?
Second chances and old history
- A mediator is assigned a dispute between two co-owners of a restaurant, and one of them is the man she left at an airport eleven years ago. Does she declare the conflict, or keep the case?
- A woman comes home to her island to sell her late aunt’s boatyard, and the only buyer is the shipwright she once meant to marry. Is she selling the yard, or the past?
- Two former dance partners, who stopped competing after a fall neither forgave, are asked to teach one last class together. Who really caused the fall?
- A songwriter’s only hit was about his ex, and she is now the radio host booked to interview him live. Does she ask about the song?
- A divorced couple who still co-own a racehorse have to travel together to the one race it might win. Is it really the horse they cannot let go of?
Arrangements and pretending
- Two rival genealogists are hired by the same family and agree to pose as partners so both can keep the fee. What do they do when the family tree turns up something the family will hate?
- To stop a strict building board from evicting him, a tenant tells them his neighbour is his live-in partner, and she has to move her things in before the inspection. How long can two people share a bathroom and nothing else?
- A sign painter needs a husband on paper to keep her workshop lease, and the only volunteer is her accountant, who has opinions about her prices. Does the marriage outlast the lease?
- Two novelists whose publishers stage a public feud to sell both books start drafting their insults together over dinner. Which part of the feud is still pretend?
- A matchmaker who has never kept a match of her own takes on a recently divorced client who rejects every candidate for reasons that sound a lot like her. When will she notice the pattern?
Strangers in close quarters
- Two strangers spend six hours in a stalled cable car above a ski resort, with one flask of tea and no signal. What do you tell someone you expect never to see again, and what if you do?
- Two contestants on a wilderness survival show are paired up after their partners quit on the first day. Is the alliance a strategy, and for which of them?
- A night printer at a newspaper and the delivery driver who collects the first bundles have twelve minutes together every morning. What happens the day one of them changes shifts?
- Two volunteers are left on a remote island for one season to count seabirds, with a supply boat once a month. What does she do when the boat finally comes to take them home?
- A wedding singer and the venue’s security guard work every wedding of the season side by side. Who notices first that they are the only two people in the room not watching the couple?
Fantasy and the strange
- A woman who hears every lie as a ringing in her ears falls for a man who has never told her one, and that is what frightens her. What is he hiding by never lying?
- Death’s newest apprentice is sent to collect a man who keeps cheating fate by accident. Will she take him, or ask to be reassigned?
- A selkie’s sealskin turns up in the lost property office of a seaside station, and the clerk is the only person who knows what it is. Does he give it back, knowing she will leave?
- A time traveller keeps arriving at the same bar in different decades, and the owner is the only one who ages between visits. How long can she wait for him?
- Every hundred years a town marries a citizen to the forest spirit. This time the spirit refuses the chosen one and asks for the clerk who counted the votes. What does the spirit know that the town does not?
Darker ones
These lean toward dark romance, so read them alongside the notes on dark romance tropes before you start.
- A forger who copies paintings for a crime family is told to train her replacement, a quiet man who paints badly and notices everything. Is he there to learn, or to watch her?
- The heir of a rival syndicate is handed over as a guarantee of peace, and the woman responsible for him has orders to keep him alive and nothing more. What happens to the truce if they choose each other?
- The man who burned down her family’s mill comes back ten years later to rebuild it stone by stone, and asks for nothing. Does she let him finish, and what is he really trying to repair?
- The man who has watched her building for weeks turns out to be guarding it, from someone she has never met. Who is he protecting her from, and why will he not say?
- A widow suspects her husband’s business partner of killing him, and he suspects her. Which of them is right, and what if neither is?
From premise to first scene
Decide the answer to the question before you write, even if you change it later. Then write the scene where the question is asked for the first time, on the page, between the two of them. For the cookbook author, it is the morning the fact-checker sets a stopwatch on her counter. For the cable car, it is the moment the lights go out.
If you want to see where one of these goes before you commit, the AI romance writer begins from the same two things: a pair of people and the obstacle between them.
Questions
What makes a good romance story idea?
Two specific people, one reason they cannot simply be together, and a question a reader wants answered. Of the three, the question is the one most often missing, and it is what makes a reader turn the page.
How do I make an old idea feel new?
Keep the question and change the job, the place or the person who wants it most. Readers forgive a familiar shape when the details are ones they have not met before.
Should I know the ending before I start writing?
It helps to know the answer to the central question, even if you change it later. The answer tells you which scenes belong in the book and which can go.